I received my payment for the review of ReviewMe I did about a month ago. The payment was sent very quickly, so I will give them another link and say, “not bad ReviewMe, not bad…”
$50 for one blog post that I could be critical of isn’t bad at all. PPP could take notes.

Robyn,
Do you even realize that PPP has offered open-ended reviews since they launched the sponsored post space? In fact, opps to review http://www.PayPerPost.com (like your RM.com review) pay bloggers to be critical, glowing, indifferent or anything in between — they always pay regardless.
I’ve noticed here and in comments elsewhere that you picked up some incorrect facts on PPP along the way. Given how strongly you feel on the topic, I’d encourage you to research/try the service firsthand so you don’t make mistakes like that. I started my diligence with some of your same misconceptions and learned through use/research that this was a team and a company worth investing in (so I did). Their model puts the blogger in control, not the marketplace, as it should be…
I appreciate your constructive criticism Dan, many are not so kind when they see an error 😉
I’ll look deeper into PPP, but I was under the impression that the advertiser could disapprove a post at will. Am I wrong in this? That’s where I get the ‘positive review required’ speak.
I saw that reviewing PPP could be positive or negative, but reviewing the actual products is different, right?
Hey Robyn,
Given that a prior post of yours specifically said “I’ll admit when I’m wrong” I hoped you’d take the feedback as it was intended, constructively. The sponsored post debate can be so heated at times that you never know how where comment threads will go, even on simple points.
Here are some answers to your questions:
Q1) “I was under the impression that the advertiser could disapprove a post at will. Am I wrong in this?”
A1) Yes, that is wrong. PayperPost advertisers do not get to approve or disapprove of a post. PayPerPost does review every post for quality (e.g. no porn/illegal, no splogs) and contractual elements (e.g. topic, min length and pix/link as requested) prior to payment, but my research has found no problems with payment for positive or negative posts.
Q2) “I saw that reviewing PPP could be positive or negative, but reviewing the actual products is different, right?”
A2) No. Unlike other sponsored post networks that offer opportunities onesy-twosy and bloggers have to decide in a vacuum whether that is the best advertiser for their blog/audience; PayPerPost offers a true marketplace of opps to choose from, leaving the blogger free to choose the topic and tone, if any, that matches their experience and audience. For example, right now there are 32 open-ended (pos/neg/neutral) ad opps and 12 tone-specific ad opps (like eBay, opps are being created and fulfilled at all times so these were just the currently active ones). I’ve seen the tone-specific ad opps used by advertisers “dipping their toe” into blog marketing, and they transition to open-ended as they gain comfort (and their marketing management gains comfort with the medium) — this is a new, scary channel to be sure. I also believe tone-specific opps get rated lower by Posties (similar to eBay buyer/seller feedback). Likewise, PPP CEO Ted Murphy, publicly recommends open-ended (pos/neg/neutral) tone for all marketers (see http://blog.payperpost.com/2006/10/attention-advertisers-keep-it-real.html) and walks-the-talk by making all PayPerPost-specific ad opps open-ended. Regardless of an opp’s tone request, the PPP blogger (or “Postie”) always has final say on taking an opp that matches their experience and audience — if they see an opp that doesn’t match, they move on to others that do (much easier when you’re not forced to make a onesy-twosy decision).
The nice thing about the sponsored post landscape is that bloggers can try all the services in parallel (don’t forget Blogitive, Blogsvertise and CreamAid) and see what works for them. Each one presents a different mix of advertisers, functions, community and fun. This thread on the PayPerPost community forums discusses some comparisons: http://boards.payperpost.com/viewtopic.php?t=1073&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0
I do hope you’ll try PPP to determine firsthand if the blogger is in control as I say. Reviewing your blog tells me you’d enjoy the topics, PPP team (see http://www.rockstartup.com/) and community of Posties.
Keep up the great blogging…
Thanks Dan. So, can advertisers specify in their tone that it must be positive?
Yes, just as bloggers can choose to pass them by and rate the advertiser lower for not leaving it open-tone. As I shared in A2 above, PPP’s CEO actively recommends open tone (http://blog.payperpost.com/2006/10/attention-advertisers-keep-it-real.html), but I talked to marketers during my due diligence that said tone-specific opps allow them to dip their toe into a space that is new to them or their management. I can understand their caution and I’m guessing you can as well. Even then, bloggers remain in 100% control of whether to take opps that match their true feelings, experiences and audience — as you would if you decided to try it out.